Many owners of good companies believe the buyers will come to them. They get a steady trickle of letters and calls from private equity firms, and it is easy to conclude that every firm that might want the business already knows about it. When the time comes to sell, the thinking goes, those firms will show up.

The data says otherwise. A 2026 benchmark of private equity deal sourcing found that the typical PE firm focused on companies worth $10 million to $49 million reviewed fewer than one in eleven of the deals that closed inside its own target criteria. Those are deals the firm would have wanted to look at, in its size range and its industries, and it never saw most of them.

This post walks through what that report measured, what the numbers say about smaller and founder-owned companies, why buyers miss so much, and what it means for how you sell. When we cite a number, we say where it came from.

What the Benchmark Measures

The source is the Deal Origination Benchmark Report 2026 from With Intelligence, a part of S&P Global, published May 27, 2026 (With Intelligence, "Deal Origination Benchmark Report 2026"). It covers full-year 2025 and aggregates data from 185 private equity firms that are With Intelligence clients. A firm is included only if it has reported its tracked deal pipeline to With Intelligence consistently for two years. The firms are split into eight peer groups by deal size and industry focus.

The report's main measure is market coverage. For each firm, coverage is the percentage of PE transactions that closed within that firm's own target criteria, with a confirmed sell-side advisor, that the firm reviewed. Put plainly: of the deals that closed which this firm would have wanted to see, how many did it actually see?

A few limits are worth knowing before reading anything into the numbers:

  • Coverage only counts deals that closed with a PE buyer and a confirmed sell-side advisor. Companies sold to strategic buyers, or sold without an advisor, are outside the measure.
  • The 185 firms are clients of a deal-sourcing data provider. Firms that pay to track their own sourcing are probably more organized about it than the average sponsor, so if anything the figures may flatter the industry.
  • The report has no valuation multiples, buyer names or geography. It describes how much of the market buyers see, not what they pay.

The Headline Number: 8.8%

The report's Lower Market peer group is made up of PE firms that mainly invest in companies with an enterprise value between $10 million and $49 million, regardless of industry. That is where many of the companies we work with sit.

In 2025, the median firm in that group reviewed 8.8% of the closed PE deals that fell inside its own criteria. A firm at the top quartile reviewed 11.8%. The single best firm in the group reviewed 16.0%.

Turn those percentages around and the picture is plain. The typical lower-market buyer did not see more than nine out of ten of the deals that matched what it says it is looking for. Even the most thorough firm in the group missed about five out of six.

The gap is not unique to small deals, but it is wider there. Across all 185 firms, median coverage was roughly 17%, about twice the lower-market figure. Larger deals tend to be run by advisors who contact more buyers, and larger buyers have more people working on sourcing. The report does not break down why the gap exists, so treat those as our explanations, not its findings.

A buyer cannot bid on a company it does not know is for sale. For most lower-middle-market deals, most of the buyers who fit never hear about it.

Founder-Owned Companies Are Seen Less

The report also splits coverage by who was selling. Within the Lower Market group, the median firm reviewed 8.8% of qualifying deals where the seller was a private company, and 12.5% where the seller was another private equity firm.

For a founder or family owner, that difference matters. When a PE firm sells one of its portfolio companies, the deal is usually run by a banker who sells to sponsors regularly, and the selling firm knows many of the likely buyers personally. A first-time seller does not start with that network. The report does not explain the gap, but the practical point holds either way: a privately owned company is less likely to be seen by the full set of buyers unless someone makes sure it is.

Sector-Focused Buyers See More

The report splits lower-middle-market firms (those targeting deals of $10 million and up) by how specialized they are. The median sector-focused firm in that size range reviewed 15.9% of the qualifying deals, against 13.3% for the middle group the report calls quasi-generalists and 11.2% for generalists.

That fits what we see. A firm that only buys industrial distributors, for example, tends to know the advisors who sell them and gets called early. A generalist fund looking at ten industries at once has more ground to cover with the same team. For a seller, it means the specialists in your industry are the most likely to find you, and the generalists, who may still be strong buyers, are the most likely to miss you.

Our post on finding the right buyer covers how a buyer list should mix these groups with strategic buyers, individual buyers and family offices.

Why Buyers Miss So Many Deals

It is tempting to read low coverage as laziness. It mostly reflects how much work it takes to evaluate a company and how few deals a firm actually closes.

The best-known academic look at this is a survey of 79 private equity firms by Paul Gompers, Steven Kaplan and Vladimir Mukharlyamov (NBER, "What Do Private Equity Firms Say They Do?", Working Paper 21133, April 2015). The firms reported that for every 100 opportunities they considered, they looked deeply at fewer than 24, signed an agreement on fewer than 14 and closed about 6. Each deal that gets serious attention takes time from a small team, so firms are selective about what they let into the funnel at all.

The same survey asked where closed deals came from. Almost 36% were proactively self-generated by the firm, and 33% came from investment banks. Smaller shares came from deal brokers (8.6%), executive networks (8.6%), management teams (7.4%) and other PE firms (4.3%). The survey is now more than a decade old and leans toward larger firms, so the exact shares will have moved. The broader point has not: a company reaches most PE buyers either because the buyer went looking for it or because an advisor put it in front of them.

Market conditions have made this harder, not easier. The With Intelligence report says lower-middle-market transaction activity was lower in 2025, that median target market size shrank across every peer group, and that fewer than half of the firms in the report exited a platform investment during the year. It also notes that the firms adapting best are building relationships with companies before they come to market and looking for new deal sources so they end up on future buyer lists. In other words, the better buyers know they are missing deals and are working to fix it. They still miss most of them.

What the Data Does Not Tell You

It is easy to stretch a statistic like this further than it goes, so a few cautions.

Coverage measures whether a buyer reviewed a deal, not whether it would have paid more. A firm that missed your sale might have passed anyway. The data shows that many fitting buyers never get the chance to decide, which is a different claim from saying any of them would have won.

The report also sorts deals by how widely they were marketed, from exclusive to broad. Those categories are based on how many of the report's own client firms reviewed each deal, so a deal is labeled broad partly because many firms saw it. That makes the categories circular as evidence for one kind of process over another, and we do not use them that way.

Last, the report covers only private equity buyers. Strategic acquirers, which often pay for synergies a financial buyer cannot count on, have their own blind spots, and this data says nothing about them.

What This Means If You Plan to Sell

Do not assume the right buyer already knows about you

The letters and calls you get are a sample of the market, and a skewed one. They come from firms that happen to run outbound campaigns in your industry. The buyer who would pay the most, or who fits your plans for your employees best, may be one that has never heard of your company.

Treat an unsolicited offer as one data point

A buyer who approaches you directly has done its homework, and it knows that if you engage without talking to anyone else, it faces no competition. The coverage data adds a second reason to be careful: most of the buyers who would want your company probably have no idea it is available. Our post on how to handle an unsolicited offer covers how to respond without giving up your position.

The buyer list is one of the biggest decisions in the sale

If buyers will not find you on their own, the list of parties your advisor contacts sets the ceiling on how much competition you get. A good list is built company by company: which sponsors own platforms in your industry and need add-ons, which generalists have bought businesses like yours, which strategic buyers would gain the most, and which individual buyers or family offices could fit. It is not a mass email to every fund in a database, and it is not a short list of the names the advisor happens to know.

Run the outreach so offers arrive together

Reaching buyers is only half of it. The other half is timing. If one buyer sees the company in March and another in July, you end up negotiating with the early one alone while the late one is still learning about the business. A well-run process sends a blind teaser to the whole list within a short window, gets nondisclosure agreements signed, releases the confidential information memorandum to everyone at about the same time and sets a common date for first-round indications of interest. Competitors and other sensitive strategic buyers may be contacted later or shown less, but the goal is the same: several serious buyers looking at the same company at the same time. Our post on the sale process step by step covers each phase.

Ask your advisor how they will reach the buyers who would not otherwise see you

Before you hire anyone to sell your company, ask concrete questions. How many private equity firms do you expect to contact, and how will you pick them? Which sponsors already own companies in our industry? Which of them have you sold to before? How will you reach the strategic buyers, and when? How will you keep the process confidential while still reaching enough buyers? The answers tell you a lot about whether the outreach will be thorough. Our post on M&A advisors vs. business brokers covers other differences worth asking about.

Prepare before buyers look

Reaching more buyers only helps if the company holds up when they look. Clean financials, a defensible add-back schedule and answers to the obvious diligence questions keep buyers in the process once they have found you. Our 12-month pre-exit checklist lays out a sequence.

Where Private Equity Fits

None of this means private equity is the right buyer for every company, or that more PE buyers is always better. Strategic acquirers, management teams and individual buyers can each be the best fit depending on what you want from the sale. Our guide on private equity in the lower middle market covers how sponsors think, how deals are structured and how to judge a PE partner. The point of the coverage data is narrower: whichever buyers you want, you cannot count on them to find you.

The buyers who fit your company exist. In 2025, the typical one in this size range saw fewer than one in eleven of the deals it was looking for, and making sure yours is one of them is part of the job of selling.

CS

Blackland Advisors advises owners of manufacturing, distribution, and transportation and logistics companies with $10 to $100 million in annual revenue on sell-side, buy-side, and strategic engagements, with offices in Atlanta, Charlotte, Nashville, and Jacksonville. Written by Chapman Syme, Founder & Managing Principal. Read his full background →