An unsolicited offer is a bid to buy your company that a buyer makes on its own initiative, before you have put the business up for sale. It usually shows up out of nowhere, with little context. Someone has decided your company is worth pursuing before you listed it, before you hired an advisor, and before you had any say in how a process would run. That can work out well for you. The side that handles the conversation better gets the advantage, though, and a buyer who makes an unsolicited approach has usually been thinking about that conversation a lot longer than you have.
Why Buyers Make Unsolicited Offers
Synergy is the most common reason. The buyer believes your capabilities, customer relationships or market position combined with its own will be worth more than the two businesses apart. Buyers like that will often pay a premium, but you only get it if you understand where the premium comes from and have someone on your side who can negotiate for it. Otherwise the buyer keeps it.
Some approaches come down to market timing: a buyer with good access to capital wants to move before competition for deals picks up. Others are portfolio fit. PE groups and larger operators regularly screen for targets that match a defined growth thesis. Our guide to private equity in the lower middle market covers how PE buyers evaluate acquisitions. Keep in mind that the firm calling you is rarely the only one that would want your company; our post on how many PE buyers actually see a deal explains why most never hear about it.
There's also a simple tactical reason. If the seller engages without talking to anyone else, the buyer faces no competition at all.
A buyer who calls you directly has done its homework and decided that skipping a competitive process works in its favor.
What Sellers Gain, and What They Risk
The main benefit is that the buyer came to you, so it's motivated, and you've skipped the work of finding and qualifying buyers. You can also explore a possible deal without committing to a full process. If the offer has you thinking seriously about timing for the first time, work through our post on how to know when it's the right time to sell.
Where sellers usually lose is on price. With no competitive process, nothing tells you what the business is worth to the full range of buyers. Before you evaluate any offer, get your normalized EBITDA independently established. Our complete guide on what EBITDA is explains every component, along with the common mistakes that let buyers argue down from a number that was already low.
Settle on your walk-away number before the first conversation, while walking away still costs you nothing.
The buyer also knows more than you do. Anyone making an unsolicited offer has already studied your customer concentration, margin profile and key-person dependencies, and you're walking in without the same preparation.
In an unsolicited situation, your advisor sets an independent valuation baseline, controls what information goes out and when, shapes a response that keeps the buyer engaged without giving up ground, and tells you whether bringing in other buyers would help you.
Managing Timing: Between Too Fast and Too Slow
Motivated buyers can lose interest or get pulled onto other priorities, so time can kill deals. A seller who answers too quickly, with no valuation baseline and no representation, tends to give up things that are hard to get back. Buyers often manufacture urgency to cut short your thinking time. Move promptly, but hire an advisor before you get into substance with the buyer.
Eight Practices for Sellers Handling an Unsolicited Offer
1. Hire an advisor before the conversation goes further. Anything you say before you have representation, you say from a weaker position.
2. Establish your own valuation baseline. Our post on business valuation drivers covers what expands or compresses your multiple.
3. Decide early what you need on price, structure, timeline and your involvement after closing, and what you won't give up, before negotiations begin.
4. Do diligence on the buyer. Its financial capacity, acquisition history and record of actually closing all matter. Our post on finding the right buyer for your business covers how to judge fit, economic and otherwise.
5. Keep it confidential, and keep the number of people who know as small as you can. Our post on keeping a business sale confidential covers NDAs and who to tell when.
6. Decide with your advisor whether to bring in competing buyers. There are real tradeoffs either way.
7. Be willing to walk away. You can't negotiate with discipline until you know where your walk-away point is.
8. Keep running your business. If it keeps performing, you have no reason to accept bad terms.
Red Flags That Warrant Heightened Scrutiny
Be careful with a buyer who manufactures urgency or applies pressure, resists normal diligence on itself, gives vague or shifting explanations of its financing, or pushes back on your hiring an advisor. Other warning signs: an implausibly high opening valuation that sets up a hard renegotiation later, consideration pushed into earnouts the buyer controls, and reluctance to put terms in writing.
When a buyer submits a formal offer and the two sides move to an LOI, a different set of risks comes into play. Read our post on 5 LOI "gotcha" clauses that can hurt sellers during exclusivity and give the LOI the same scrutiny as the offer.
The offer will still be there in a few days. Use that time to get a valuation baseline and an advisor in place before you answer.