Earnouts show up in offer letters, purchase agreements and advisor pitches, almost always wrapped in a phrase about "bridging the valuation gap." Few people stop to explain what one means for the seller in plain terms, or why so many sellers only see the risk after they've signed.

What Is an Earnout?

An earnout is a provision in the purchase agreement that pays the seller more money after closing if the business hits specified performance targets over a defined period. The buyer pays an agreed amount at close. If the business hits the milestone, the seller gets the earnout payment. If it doesn't, the seller gets nothing beyond what was paid up front.

The buyer uses an earnout to push uncertainty about the future onto the seller.

In our experience, earnouts appear in 20-30% of private company acquisitions. Earnout value is usually a multiple of EBITDA, the same number that anchors the base price, so read our guide on what EBITDA is before you evaluate one.

Buyers propose earnouts when what they'll pay on historical results falls short of what the seller thinks the business is worth on projections. The usual triggers are a valuation gap on projected performance, key-person transition risk, customer concentration or contract uncertainty, and fast growth on a short operating history.

How an Earnout Is Structured

Start with the metric. Revenue-based earnouts are harder to manipulate through expense allocation, though they can pull the buyer's and seller's incentives apart. EBITDA-based earnouts are more common and riskier, because the buyer controls the post-close expense base and every dollar of cost it books reduces your number.

The period is usually one to three years, most often two. A multi-year period with a cumulative catch-up provision sounds seller-friendly, but in practice it doubles the time before you know whether the earnout paid.

Payment can be structured three ways. A binary trigger (full amount or nothing) is the simplest and the worst for the seller. A linear or proportional structure pays the same percentage of the earnout as the percentage of target achieved. A tiered structure splits the earnout into tranches at different performance levels, which protects the downside and keeps the upside.

In the deals we see, the amount is typically 10-30% of total enterprise value. The bigger the earnout relative to total consideration, the more the protective provisions matter.

Take an earnout worth 40% of transaction value with a binary trigger, an EBITDA metric and no operating covenants. The buyer has agreed to pay 60 cents on the dollar today and 40 cents at its own discretion. You have sold the buyer an option, and you paid for it.

When an Earnout Is Appropriate

An earnout makes sense when it's tied to one identifiable forward risk, rather than the general question of whether the business keeps performing. Reasonable uses: retention risk on a major customer you only recently won, founder transition risk where you stay involved during the earnout period, and a fast-growing business whose short history doesn't yet support the seller's price.

Before you accept any earnout, ask whether it covers a specific forward risk that is actually uncertain, or whether it just cuts the buyer's upfront check for earnings you've already shown in the historical numbers. If it's the second, it's a discount and you should negotiate against it.

When Earnouts Go Wrong

In our experience, somewhere between 30-50% of earnouts don't pay out in full. The most common cause is expense allocation. Unless the contract restricts it, a buyer can push shared costs (management fees, IT overhead, insurance) onto the acquired business and cut reported EBITDA with no change in how the business actually performs. Decisions that make sense for the combined company, like redirecting sales people or bundling product lines, can also depress standalone results with no bad faith involved.

If the metric is EBITDA and the agreement doesn't spell out the methodology, expect a dispute. Those disputes are expensive and slow, and plenty of them end in litigation. Sellers also tend to miss that earnout language usually gets locked in at the LOI, well before anyone drafts the purchase agreement. Our guide on 5 LOI gotcha clauses covers vague earnout terms along with the other provisions that cost sellers the most once exclusivity is granted.

The Protective Provisions Every Earnout Should Include

If you can't avoid an earnout, insist on at least these: an ordinary course operating covenant requiring the buyer to run the business the way it was run before closing; a bar on new or increased shared-cost allocations without your consent; an independent mechanism for resolving disputed calculations; a precisely defined EBITDA methodology if that's the metric; acceleration on change of control, so a sale mid-earnout triggers full payment; and an anti-sandbagging covenant that prohibits managing the business toward a missed target. A three-word EBITDA definition will end in a fight. If EBITDA is the metric, go through our guide What Is EBITDA? so you know every component of the calculation, then make sure the purchase agreement defines each one for earnout measurement.

Earnouts and Taxes

Earnout tax treatment is complicated and you need a qualified CPA for it. What follows is general orientation, not tax advice. Earnout payments treated as additional purchase price are generally taxed as capital gains, which is the most favorable treatment. Payments structured as compensation for continued services may be taxed as ordinary income. The purchase agreement should characterize earnout payments as consideration for the sale, and the drafting deserves care. Whether the deal is an asset sale or a stock sale also affects this; our guide on asset sale vs. stock sale tax implications covers each.

Before you sign, work out whether the earnout on the table covers a real forward risk or simply defers part of your price at the buyer's discretion.

CS

Chapman Syme is the Founder and Managing Principal of Blackland Advisors, a lower middle market M&A advisory firm based in the Southeast, with offices in Atlanta, Charlotte, Nashville, and Jacksonville, working with companies generating $10 to $100 million in annual revenue, many of which are family-owned and preparing for generational transition. Read Chapman's full background →